The myanmar emergency medicine
development program
A briefing paper – April 2013
Emergency Medicine definition
Emergency medicine is a field of practice based on
the knowledge
and skills
required for the prevention, diagnosis and management
of acute
and urgent aspects of illness and injury
affecting patients of all age groups
with a full spectrum of episodic undifferentiated physical and behavioural
disorders; it further encompasses an understanding of the
development of prehospital and inhospital emergency medical systems
and the skills necessary for this development.
International Federation of
Emergency Medicine
Emergency care in Myanmar
Emergency Medicine (EM) and Emergency Medical Systems (EMS) are
an essential component of all developed world health care systems. Myanmar has missed out on the wave of
Emergency Medicine development that has occurred worldwide due to its
international isolation over the last 3 – 4 decades. Consequently, EM and EMS
are grossly underdeveloped. There are currently no nationally trained doctors
that have the broad set of knowledge and skills of an emergency medicine
specialist doctor. This impacts the quality of emergency care delivery in
hospitals, the quality of EM and EMS policy, guidelines and standards at the
ministry level, and the quality of EM teaching for current doctors and undergraduate
training of future doctors. This has had a flow on effect that has impacted the
quality of emergency care of patients across Myanmar in all districts and
states, both urban and rural.
The Myanmar Emergency Development Program (MEMDP) is a
comprehensive program that is designed to address this. It is not disease or
age specific but is aimed to improve the overall systematic care of all
patients requiring emergency care, including those who have illnesses
identified as WHO priorities.
Background of Myanmar emergency medicine development program (memdp)
In 2009 a core group of International medical specialists began
collaborating with local doctors to improve emergency care training in Myanmar.
It began with a simple primary trauma care (PTC) course (www.primarytraumacare.org)
requested after Cyclone Nargis, and has now progressed to a larger, more
comprehensive Myanmar Emergency Medicine Development Program (MEMDP).
In early 2012, a consensus workshop held between Myanmar
clinical and academic leaders and international experts established the clear
need and desire to develop an emergency medicine system (EMS) that included
hospital and pre-hospital services. A formal ‘Letter of Intent’ was signed
between the Myanmar Ministry of Health- Departments of Health and Medical
Science, the Australasian College for Emergency Medicine (ACEM), the
International Federation for Emergency Medicine (IFEM) and the Royal
Australasian College for Surgeons (RACS). The document confirmed the desire and
intent of the Ministry of Health to develop the specialty of EM in Myanmar in
collaboration and with support of the international partners. The Myanmar
Ministry of Health views this collaboration as part of the Myanmar Australia
bilateral cooperation in the development of the health sector.
Brief Program description
Development of Emergency Medicine (EM) and EMS has been planned
over a 3-phase program.
An overview of what is a dynamic and evolving program is
outlined below.
Phase
1
Following that, they will be the
future of EM and EMS development, training, and provision of emergency care and
its dissemination throughout Myanmar.
Phase 2
Phase 2 is the natural progression of Phase 1. It is
designed to extend the Diploma into a Masters of Medical Science – Emergency Medicine
course. This will thus develop EM as a specialty within Myanmar at an equivalent
level to other medical specialty disciplines and enable doctors to enter the
training program at a junior level. It is likely to be a 3 year program. It requires formal curriculum development
with academic and clinical teaching, research and assessment embedded at both
University and public hospital levels and the recruitment of dynamic and
committed trainees. Forward projections
predict there will be fully trained emergency specialists graduating from 2016
onwards and adding these to the phase 1 pool of 18 will make a total emergency
specialist workforce of 38 available. At
this time, their deployment across the country at state and district level will
then start to have an even greater impact on emergency care provision to the
greater Myanmar population.
Phase 3
Phase 3 is the capacity building program for parts of EM/EMS
development required to achieve maturity. It will establish EM as a formal
faculty within the Universities and Ministry of Health and extend emergency
care teaching to undergraduates and junior medical officers. It also includes
emergency nurse training, prehospital development of an ambulance service, as
well as the up-skilling of primary care doctors throughout the country. Other aspects
may include supporting process change, physical designs of departments and support
for change implementation.
It has already partially commenced concurrently with Phase
1. Most of the courses delivered as part of Phase 1 were delivered with the
goal of training local instructors so that the courses may ultimately be
delivered in Myanmar without the assistance of an international faculty. They
will initially be aimed at developing a larger local instructor pool as well as
training junior doctors at the level of civil assistant surgeon (CAS). The
instructor pool will include some of the Phase 1 trainees for each course, but
additional instructors will be sourced from appropriate specialist groups. For
example, medical doctors such as cardiologists and internal medicine
specialists will be sources for the ELS course focused on medical emergencies.
The Pain Course will target members of the Pain Society as well as oncologists
and rehabilitation doctors who see a lot of chronic pain. The Teaching Course will
target senior consultants who are taking on more teaching responsibilities, and
the paediatric courses will target both paediatric trainees, and CAS doctors
who see paediatric emergencies. The surgical and trauma courses will target
trainees in specialties involved in trauma care. CAS doctors will be the concurrent focus of
all courses. They all go on to serve at least 2 years at district level
hospitals. In this way, emergency care development will spread throughout the
country.
The Primary Trauma Care courses have already demonstrated that
this model of propagation and amplification is successful with over 35 PTC courses
delivered throughout Myanmar since 2009. Ambulance crew training by the Phase 1
trainees has also commenced.
Key program coordinators.
The formal international program partners are the
Australasian College for Emergency Medicine (ACEM), the Royal Australasian
College of Surgeons (RACS) and the International Federation of Emergency
Medicine (IFEM).
The program as a whole is unfunded, has no overall
administration capacity and has been administered so far in a fully voluntary
fashion. By the end of 2013, the number
of international teachers and facilitators from Australia and Hong Kong that
will have visited Myanmar and participated voluntarily in various parts of this
program will be greater than 45 including specialists in emergency, surgery,
anaesthetics, paediatrics, and emergency nursing. The strength and success of
this program has relied heavily on its ability to combine resources from
multiple countries, specialties, regions, hospitals and training universities
and colleges.
The key contacts involved in coordinating this large program voluntarily with many other helpers are as follows;
The key contacts involved in coordinating this large program voluntarily with many other helpers are as follows;
Professor Zaw Wai Soe
Co-Secretary Emergency Medicine Development Program
Professor of Orthopaedics and Traumatology
University of Medicine 1, Yangon General Hospital,
MYANMAR
Dr James Kong FRACS
International Program Coordinator, Myanmar Emergency
Development Program
Director of Surgery, Asia Medical Specialists, HONG
KONG
Dr Georgina Phillips FACEM
Emergency Physician, St. Vincent's Hospital,
Melbourne AUSTRALIA
International EM Special Interest Group
Dr Chris Curry FACEM
Emergency Physician, Fremantle Hospital, WA,
AUSTRALIA
International EM Special Interest Group
Dr Michael
Augello FACEM
Emergency Physician, St. Vincent's
Hospital, Melbourne AUSTRALIA
International EM Special Interest
Group
Sponsors
Whilst there is no overall funding source, numerous funding
sources have sponsored or are committed to sponsoring various requirement of
the program so far on top of significant personal leave contributions by most
of the facilitators.
The 2013 voluntary long term Emergency Physician country
placements as well as the coordination visits of James Kong have received no
financial support other than some airfares and have relied heavily on the generosity
of Professor Zaw Wai Soe who has hosted our accommodation and food during our
long term visits.
Some of Phase 1 and Most of Phase 3 have no funding source.
The immense amount of voluntary goodwill will not be able to sustain this
program. AVI are supporting 2 positions for
a long term Emergency Physician based at the University of Yangon (1) for the
Phase 2 and 3 components of the program, which are in the process of being
filled. AVI have also advertised for ambulance trainer positions to assist in ambulance
and EMS development based at Yangon, Nay Pyi Taw and Mandalay.
Further funding is required for the overall administrative
and coordination of this program, exam preparation and examinations later in
2013, additional collaboration for Phase 2 development, and other aspects of
phase 3 development including but not limited to course propagation,
commencement of nurse training, and research into the effects of the program.
Other parts of phase 3 such as a skills and training centre that extends beyond
emergency medicine are still in development.
The Future
The Myanmar EM development program is a long-term
collaboration with far reaching yet achievable objectives that has so far
demonstrated enormous success in coordinating international partners and
volunteers.
The future components of the program will continue to be
developed, although will be difficult to sustain on a purely volunteer basis
using personal leave time and without formal funding or administrative support.
Work to secure a long-term funding partnership and development assistance
framework is ongoing, whilst not compromising the excellent in-country
relationships that have been formed and the primacy of the emergency medicine
clinical input.
Iast updated May 2013